Skip to content
AutographsForSale.com AutographsForSale.com
  • FACEBOOK

    • Big Markdowns on Framed Autographs

    All Ready to Hang

    Shop now

    Indianapolis Colts Memorabilia

    Filter

    47 products

    • Sort by

    Eric Dickerson autographed Indianapolis Colts Champion blue jersey JSA - AutographsForSale.com
    Sold out
    Eric Dickerson autographed Indianapolis Colts Champion blue jersey JSA
    $229.29
    Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 2002 & 2005 Sports Illustrated for Kids - AutographsForSale.com
    40% OFF
    Sale
    Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 2002 & 2005 Sports Illustrated for Kids
    $7.50$12.50
    2 Indianapolis Colts Sports Illustrated issues Andrew Luck Reggie Wayne - AutographsForSale.com
    2 Indianapolis Colts Sports Illustrated issues Andrew Luck Reggie Wayne
    $7.50
    Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts 1997 Leaf 8x10 photo card - AutographsForSale.com
    70% OFF
    Sale
    Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts 1997 Leaf 8x10 photo card
    $1.50$5.00
    Art Donovan Gino Marchetti Lenny Moore 2014 Leaf Masterpiece Cut Signature card 1/1 Colts - AutographsForSale.com
    23% OFF
    Sale
    Art Donovan Gino Marchetti Lenny Moore 2014 Leaf Masterpiece Cut Signature card 1/1 Colts
    $64.99$84.99
    Peyton Manning signed Indianapolis Colts mini helmet JSA - AutographsForSale.com
    18% OFF
    Sale
    Peyton Manning signed Indianapolis Colts mini helmet JSA
    $244.44$299.99
    Bubba Smith Baltimore Colts 1972 Topps card - AutographsForSale.com
    Bubba Smith Baltimore Colts 1972 Topps card
    $1.50
    Peyton Manning autographed Indianapolis Colts 8x10 photo JSA - AutographsForSale.com
    20% OFF
    Sold out
    Peyton Manning autographed Indianapolis Colts 8x10 photo JSA
    $159.99$199.99
    Edgerrin James signed Indianapolis Colts Puma game model jersey PSA/DNA - AutographsForSale.com
    16% OFF
    Sale
    Edgerrin James signed Indianapolis Colts Puma game model jersey PSA/DNA
    $332.32$399.99
    Andrew Luck Indianapolis Colts 2018 Nike Elite game model blue jersey New - AutographsForSale.com
    Andrew Luck Indianapolis Colts 2018 Nike Elite game model blue jersey New
    $234.56
    Art Donovan autographed Baltimore Colts 8x10 photo - AutographsForSale.com
    33% OFF
    Sale
    Art Donovan autographed Baltimore Colts 8x10 photo
    $29.99$45.00
    Johnny Unitas autographed Baltimore Colts 8x10 photo inscribed HOF 79 JSA - AutographsForSale.com
    62% OFF
    Sold out
    Johnny Unitas autographed Baltimore Colts 8x10 photo inscribed HOF 79 JSA
    $119.99$320.00
    Marshall Faulk certified signed Indianapolis Colts 1997 Leaf 8x10 card - AutographsForSale.com
    75% OFF
    Sale
    Marshall Faulk certified signed Indianapolis Colts 1997 Leaf 8x10 card
    $24.99$99.99
    Indianapolis Colts 2012 to 2018 Nike Elite game model blue jersey BLANK NEW - AutographsForSale.com
    36% OFF
    Sale
    Indianapolis Colts 2012 to 2018 Nike Elite game model blue jersey BLANK NEW
    $88.88$139.99
    Johnny Unitas autographed mini Wilson NFL football JSA Colts - AutographsForSale.com
    31% OFF
    Sale
    Johnny Unitas autographed mini Wilson NFL football JSA Colts
    $219.00$319.19
    Dwight Freeney Indianapolis Colts 2012 last season Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW - AutographsForSale.com
    Dwight Freeney Indianapolis Colts 2012 last season Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW
    $234.56
    Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts 2016 last season Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW - AutographsForSale.com
    Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts 2016 last season Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW
    $234.56
    Reggie Wayne Indianapolis Colts 2014 last season Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW - AutographsForSale.com
    Reggie Wayne Indianapolis Colts 2014 last season Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW
    $234.56
    Gino Marchetti autographed cut Baltimore Colts jersey number - AutographsForSale.com
    Gino Marchetti autographed cut Baltimore Colts jersey number
    $9.99
    Tony Siragusa autographed blank business card Colts Ravens - AutographsForSale.com
    Tony Siragusa autographed blank business card Colts Ravens
    $19.99
    Dwight Freeney autographed blank business card Colts - AutographsForSale.com
    Dwight Freeney autographed blank business card Colts
    $9.99
    Edgerrin James signed 2006 ESPN magazine JSA Arizona Cardinals Colts - AutographsForSale.com
    16% OFF
    Sale
    Edgerrin James signed 2006 ESPN magazine JSA Arizona Cardinals Colts
    $49.99$60.00
    Earl Morrall Baltimore Colts 1970 Topps card ExMt - AutographsForSale.com
    20% OFF
    Sold out
    Earl Morrall Baltimore Colts 1970 Topps card ExMt
    $1.99$2.50
    Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 1999 Sports Illustrated & 2009 ESPN magazine - AutographsForSale.com
    40% OFF
    Sale
    Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 1999 Sports Illustrated & 2009 ESPN magazine
    $7.50$12.50
    Marshall Faulk autographed Indianapolis Colts 1996 Upper Deck SPx hologram card BAS - AutographsForSale.com
    Sold out
    Marshall Faulk autographed Indianapolis Colts 1996 Upper Deck SPx hologram card BAS
    $49.99
    Jim Harbaugh autographed Indianapolis Colts cap hat JSA - AutographsForSale.com
    16% OFF
    Sale
    Jim Harbaugh autographed Indianapolis Colts cap hat JSA
    $49.99$60.00
    Indianapolis Colts 2015 coaches Nike On Field Dri-Fit shirt NEW - AutographsForSale.com
    70% OFF
    Sold out
    Indianapolis Colts 2015 coaches Nike On Field Dri-Fit shirt NEW
    $12.00$40.00
    Indianapolis Colts New Era On Field black & blue cap or hat fitted size 8 3/8 - AutographsForSale.com
    28% OFF
    Sold out
    Indianapolis Colts New Era On Field black & blue cap or hat fitted size 8 3/8
    $8.88$12.50
    Eric Dickerson signed Indianapolis Colts 1991 Sports Illustrated magazine JSA - AutographsForSale.com
    Eric Dickerson signed Indianapolis Colts 1991 Sports Illustrated magazine JSA
    $49.99
    Indianapolis Colts New Era On Field blue cap or hat fitted size 7 1/4 - AutographsForSale.com
    28% OFF
    Sold out
    Indianapolis Colts New Era On Field blue cap or hat fitted size 7 1/4
    $8.88$12.50
    Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts 1995 Sports Illustrated for Kids card BGS Graded 8 NrMt-Mt - AutographsForSale.com
    80% OFF
    Sold out
    Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts 1995 Sports Illustrated for Kids card BGS Graded 8 NrMt-Mt
    $14.99$77.77
    Darius (Shaquille) Leonard Indianapolis Colts 2018 Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW - AutographsForSale.com
    33% OFF
    Sale
    Darius (Shaquille) Leonard Indianapolis Colts 2018 Nike Elite game model blue jersey NEW
    $234.56$353.53

    Indianapolis Colts Autographed Memorabilia & Collectibles

    Explore authentic Indianapolis Colts memorabilia and signed collectibles, featuring certified autographs from Hall of Famers and franchise legends. This collection includes Indianapolis Colts autographed memorabilia such as jerseys, mini helmets, photo cards, magazines, and unique cut signature cards, with trusted authentication from JSA and PSA/DNA where noted.

    Serious collectors will find a curated selection spanning both the Indianapolis and Baltimore Colts eras, with items representing iconic players and historic moments. Every piece is chosen for authenticity and collector value, ensuring confidence in your investment.

    Highlights include:

    • Signed jerseys (Nike Elite, Champion, Puma game models)
    • Autographed mini helmets and footballs
    • Certified signed photo cards and 8x10 photos
    • Vintage and modern Sports Illustrated & ESPN magazines
    • Cut signature cards and framed memorabilia
    • Collectibles from Hall of Famers, MVPs, and Colts legends

    Build your Colts collection with confidence, knowing each item is backed by reputable authentication and a focus on genuine, high-quality memorabilia. as the source content and convert it into clean, bulk-export-friendly HTML following these rules:

    FAQs About Indianapolis Colts Memorabilia

    • You’ll find a range of Indianapolis Colts memorabilia including autographed jerseys, signed mini helmets, certified photo cards, vintage magazines, and unique cut signature cards from both Baltimore and Indianapolis eras.

    • All autographed memorabilia is authenticated by trusted third-party services such as JSA, PSA/DNA, or comes with certification from reputable sources, ensuring collector confidence.

    • What is the difference between signed and autographed Indianapolis Colts memorabilia?
      Both terms refer to items personally signed by players, but “autographed” often highlights official authentication, while “signed” may refer to any item bearing a player’s signature.

    • Yes, the selection includes Nike Elite and Puma game model jerseys from various player eras, as well as memorabilia featuring legends like Peyton Manning, Johnny Unitas, and Andrew Luck.

    • These certified collectibles are ideal for serious collectors, sports enthusiasts, and make impressive display pieces or thoughtful gifts for Colts fans.

    • Memorabilia is sourced directly from reputable signings, certified dealers, and established authentication events to ensure genuine, high-quality collectibles.
    Text/Call 858.384.7057
    Shipping/Returns
    Read Our Blog
    Accessibility/Privacy
    Coupon

    Drawer Title

    Similar Products