Skip to content
Top rated autograph memorabilia logo with marker pen and 'Since 1999' text. Logo with a black marker pen, red AFS letters, and green circular border, signifying autographs.

Big Markdowns on Framed Autographs

All Ready to Hang

Shop now

Autographs, Cards & Memorabilia Under $25

Filter

4690 products

  • Sort by

NotreDame - AutographsForSale.com
2 Notre Dame ESPN Sports Illustrated issues Jimmy Clausen Maurice Stovall
$7.50
FloridaState - AutographsForSale.com
3 Florida State ESPN Sports Illustrated issues Jameis Winston Warrick Dunn
$11.11
LSU - AutographsForSale.com
2 LSU Sports Illustrated issues Kevin Faulk Leonard Fournette
$11.11
Florida - AutographsForSale.com
2 Florida Gators Sports Illustrateds Chris Leak Danny Wuerffel
$11.11
UCLA - AutographsForSale.com
3 UCLA Sports Illustrated issues Brett Hundley Josh Rosen
$11.11
Clemson - AutographsForSale.com
3 Clemson Sports Illustrated issues Deshaun Watson National Champs
$14.99
Auburn - AutographsForSale.com
2 Auburn Cam Newton Sports Illustrated issues National Champs
$11.11
Nebraska - AutographsForSale.com
Nebraska football Sports Illustrated issues Eric Crouch Tommie Frazier
$11.11
Texas - AutographsForSale.com
Texas Longhorns Sports Illustrated issues Ricky Williams Vince Young
$11.11
BenGrieve1994Classic4Sport - AutographsForSale.com
Ben Grieve autographed 1994 Classic 4-Sport Draft Picks card
$3.99
OhioState - AutographsForSale.com
Ezekiel Elliott & Braxton Miller Ohio State Sports Illustrated issues
$11.11
Georgia - AutographsForSale.com
Marcus Stroud & JT Daniels Georgia Bulldogs Sports Illustrateds
$4.00
JoeCarter1990UD - AutographsForSale.com
50% OFF
Sale
Joe Carter autographed Cleveland Indians 1990 Upper Deck card
$7.50$15.00
JoeCarter1986Fleer - AutographsForSale.com
50% OFF
Sale
Joe Carter autographed Cleveland Indians 1986 Fleer card
$7.50$15.00
Indians - AutographsForSale.com
7 signed Indians 1988 Topps cards Jay Bell RC Joe Carter Brook Jacoby Pat Tabler
$24.99
JoeCarter1987Topps_ff801a06-e420-4d97-b2e4-4b9a70911c07 - AutographsForSale.com
50% OFF
Sale
Joe Carter autographed Cleveland Indians 1987 Topps card
$7.50$15.00
RickyWilliams - AutographsForSale.com
2 Ricky Williams Dolphins magazines 2002 Sports Illustrated 2003 SI Kids
$14.99
Falcons - AutographsForSale.com
2 Falcons Sports Illustrated or SI Kids issues Julio Jones Michael Vick
$7.50
Colts - AutographsForSale.com
2 Indianapolis Colts Sports Illustrated issues Andrew Luck Reggie Wayne
$7.50
Raiders - AutographsForSale.com
2 Oakland Raiders Sports Illustrated magazines Rich Gannon Khalil Mack
$7.50
Lions - AutographsForSale.com
3 Detroit Lions ESPN & Sports Illustrated issues Calvin Johnson Ndamukong Suh
$12.00
Titans - AutographsForSale.com
4 Tennessee Titans SI magazines Eddie George Chris Johnson
$14.99
NYJets - AutographsForSale.com
5 NY Jets ESPN & Sports Illustrated magazines Darrelle Revis
$14.99
NYGiants - AutographsForSale.com
4 NY Giants Sports Illustrated issues Mark Bavaro Lawrence Taylor David Tyree
$14.99
Vikings - AutographsForSale.com
5 Vikings Sports Illustrated & SI for Kids Randy Moss Cris Carter Brett Favre
$20.10
Saints - AutographsForSale.com
Drew Brees & Jonathan Vilma 2010 New Orleans Saints Sports Illustrated
$9.99
Ravens - AutographsForSale.com
4 Ravens SI Sporting News magazines Jamal & Ray Lewis John Harbaugh
$14.99
Eagles - AutographsForSale.com
6 Philadelphia Eagles SI ESPN magazines Donovan McNabb LeSean McCoy Foles
$20.15
49ers - AutographsForSale.com
7 49ers SI & ESPN magazines Colin Kaepernick Alex Smith Jim Harbaugh
$20.18
Panthers - AutographsForSale.com
6 Carolina Panthers ESPN Sports Illustrated SI Kids issues Cam Newton
$20.15
Broncos - AutographsForSale.com
6 Broncos ESPN Sports Illustrated SI Kids issues Peyton Manning Von Miller
$24.99
Rams - AutographsForSale.com
3 LA Rams Sports Illustrated issues Isaac Bruce Aaron Donald Jared Goff
$20.16

Certified Autographs & Memorabilia Under $25

Start your collection or find the perfect small gift with our selection of authenticated autographs priced under $25. Every item in this collection is certified by JSA, BAS (Beckett), or PSA/DNA — proof that genuine signed memorabilia doesn't have to be expensive.

What's Available Under $25

  • Autographed trading cards from athletes and celebrities
  • Signed postcards and index cards
  • Small signed photos and cut signatures
  • Perfect stocking stuffers and party favors for fans

These are ideal entry-level collectibles for new hobbyists and young fans just getting into the hobby. They also make excellent stocking stuffers and impulse gifts. Despite the low price, every piece is fully authenticated — no compromises on quality or legitimacy.

Frequently Asked Questions About Certified Autographs & Memorabilia Under $25

  • For under $25, you can find certified autographed trading cards, signed postcards, autographed index cards, and select signed photos from athletes, entertainers, and historical figures. Many of these items feature signatures authenticated by JSA, BAS, or PSA/DNA, ensuring you receive a genuine autograph at an accessible price. This is one of the most affordable ways to start or expand an authenticated memorabilia collection.

  • Yes, every item in our under-$25 collection has been authenticated by a recognized third-party service such as JSA (James Spence Authentication), BAS (Beckett Authentication Services), or PSA/DNA. The low price reflects the item type and the athlete's market value, not a compromise in authentication standards. Each piece includes the same verifiable hologram and certification that accompanies our higher-priced inventory.

  • Autographs under $25 are perfect stocking stuffers, party favors, and affordable gifts for sports fans of all ages. A certified signed trading card or photo makes a unique and thoughtful present that stands out from generic gifts, especially for kids and young collectors just developing an interest in sports. The included certificate of authenticity adds a special touch that elevates the gift beyond its modest price.

  • Every item under $25 is backed by the same quality and authenticity guarantees we offer across our entire inventory. The autograph has been verified by a professional authentication service, and the item itself is inspected for condition before being listed for sale. If you have any concerns about your purchase, our customer service team is available to assist with questions, returns, or exchanges.

  • Our under-$25 collection features autographs from a diverse mix of athletes including current and former professional players from the NFL, NBA, MLB, and NHL, as well as Olympic athletes, college stars, and select entertainment figures. While you may not find the biggest superstars at this price point, there are plenty of recognizable names and fan favorites available. This range is ideal for discovering new players to collect or picking up autographs from athletes you follow closely.
Text/Call 858.384.7057
Shipping/Returns
Read Our Blog
Accessibility/Privacy
Coupon

Drawer Title

Similar Products